My brother forwarded this link to me. It’s a truly excellent and heartfelt essay written by Colin Goh and his wife. Everyone should read it.
(exerpt) …And no doubt it was the Dream, fueled by hard work and courage, that has made Singapore the indisputable commercial success it is today. And our story is a wonderful one: the Little Island That Could.
However, invariably once people attain success, they start to canonize the steps they took to achievement. This is how Dreams become Plans, and how one hegemony replaces another: the search for peace and liberty becomes get into a good school, then a good university, then a stable job, then buy property and stock. The problem is, then what?
There is nothing inherently unique about the Singaporean Dream. The American Dream of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness is substantially the same. (And especially in the upper middle class, the American Dream is fast becoming a Plan too: prep school, Ivy League, Wall Street.)
But what to me gives America more hope is that they still celebrate mavericks; they may never find happiness, but their liberty to pursue it is sacred.
My experience in Singapore was, however, very different. There were always people telling you what and how you should do things, and imposing penalties for deviation. There were ‘right’ schools, ‘right’ professions, ‘right’ strategies.
Of course there are those who would argue that ultimately, the choice is one’s own and that there is nothing to prevent one from doing what he or she wants in Singapore. After all, isn’t it one’s fault for caving in to peer pressure? I would humbly submit that while theoretically true, such an argument betrays an ignorance of the combined workings of hegemony and power.
The issue is how expansive the reigning ideology is. In Singapore, the dominant view is to do whatever works (whatever that may be, and regardless of who it worked for). In New York (I won’t pretend that America is homogeneous), the prevailing view is that everyone should find what makes him or herself unique, and capitalize on that.
I am never comfortable making any kind of US vs. Singapore comparisons because it seems too apples vs. oranges. There are so many excuses to make for Singapore when one does the xxx Western country vs. Singapore comparison: we don’t have the luxury of space (you can have a New York and a buttfuck Alabama in the same country) and population, we don’t have a long enough history, yadda yadda yadda. But, Colin and Joyceln make some very heartfelt arguments that I concur with. When Joyceln writes about overhearing conversations at work, I am reminded of the conversations I hear at work about children’s schools, how good/bad their maids are, where the latest sale is, where to buy the best mooncake, what car they have, which hawker center has the best chwee kuay, and the next packaged 5D/6N S$1,499 per person tour to Seoul they will take their kids, as I glaze my eyes over.
And yet, I have so much love for this country that made me; but Singapore has so much potential to be a truly vibrant place, the powers that be just have to STFU about it and let it happen and not try to Plan the Dream out in a set path.
Criticism and disagreement is not treason, and our words emanate as much from our dissatisfaction with, as our love for Singapore. We simply believe that we are more than our legacy. This is the dream of immigrants everywhere, whether they arrive in Singapore or on Ellis Island.